First Shift is new goods: fandom favorites, oddball finds, cute stuff, and a little creepy. Second Shift puts vintage and secondhand pieces back in rotation. Check each listing for the item’s condition.

Orders ship within 1–3 business days. Carrier transit time comes after that. We currently ship within the United States only.

Reach $40 after discounts, before tax, and U.S. Ground shipping is free. Below $40, your shipping rate appears at checkout.

Choose a buyer-paid Express option at checkout. It speeds up delivery—not our 1–3 business-day processing time.

Yes—mix eligible designs within pins, stickers, or keychains. Each category has its own quantity requirement; a pin, a sticker, and a keychain do not count as three of one category. Eligible category deals apply automatically.

Overlapping category tiers do not add together on the same item. The best eligible deal applies automatically. Check your final checkout total for the savings that apply to your order.

Start with the listing’s actual measurements—not just the tagged size. Lay a similar piece you already love flat and compare its pit-to-pit width, length, shoulders, and sleeves where listed. See How We Measure → for diagrams and the exact starting points. Need a closer look? Ask before you grab it.

New or secondhand, request a return within 14 days after delivery. For fit or change of mind, you pay return shipping. Items must come back in the condition received, without additional wear, washing, or alterations. Contact us before sending anything back.

Give us a shout with your order number and details of the issue. If we sent the wrong item, or it arrived damaged or materially different from its description, we cover return shipping.